Sports Card Insurance

Protecting a Card Collector's Passion and Investment from Theft Loss Damage

Insurance for Card Collections

As lifelong card collectors ourselves, we know that card collectors can use all the help they can get to protect their rare sports cards. Most enthusiastic collectors of valuable sports cards have  large collections of rare collectibles in their possession.  Whether rare cards from the past, recent redemption cards, PSA or Beckett graded cards, autographs, complete sets or just collections of certain players, protecting these collectibles is essential.

Private Collection Insurance (PCI) recognizes that sports card collections hold tremendous nostalgia and represent cherished memories, unbelievable pulls and and significant investment pieces. PCI specializes in providing customized insurance solutions for high-value collectibles, including sports cards, memorabilia, jewellery, fine art and more.

From highly sought-after rookie cards to limited edition releases, we understand the unique value and significance of these items in the world of sports memorabilia. We’ve had many of our own sports cards evaluated by professional grading companies based on factors like condition, centering, edges, corners, and surface quality. We know that cards are assigned a numerical grade, typically from 1 to 10, with higher grades indicating superior quality that instill market confidence and premium pricing.

Our tailored insurance solutions protect against loss, theft, damage, or market fluctuations, allowing collectors to focus on their passion for rare sports cards with peace of mind. Don’t let accidents, natural disasters, or theft jeopardize your precious card collection. We help you preserve the value and sentiment of your investments with our robust protection.

Advantages of Insuring a Sports Card Collection

    • Accurate Valuation: We base coverage on appraised or market value to reflect your cards’ true worth.
    • All-Risk Protection: From theft and fire to accidental damage, our policies cover all the essentials; even incidents that occur in transit, at card shows or in storage.
    • Worldwide Coverage: Whether at home, a card show, or in transit, your collection stays protected.
    • Affordable Graded Card Insurance Options: Flexible premiums for collections of all sizes.
    • Fast Claims Process: Work with adjusters who understand the nuances of sports memorabilia insurance.
    • Coverage for Display and Exhibition Risks: Insurance for cards displayed in cases or at exhibitions, including accidental damage or theft during public viewings.
    • Loss of Value Coverage: Protection against the depreciation of value due to damage, even if the card is professionally restored.
    •  

Is Your Sports Cards Collection
Properly Covered?

START YOUR QUOTE

Fill out our application now to protect your prized collection of rookie cards, redemptions, autographs and complete sets. Our sports card insurance coverage  is designed for collectors like you.​

Potential Risks to Card Collectors

  • Theft of High-Value Sports Cards: Sports cards are a prime target for thieves due to their compact size, portability, and substantial market value. Collectors often amass valuable cards that can be worth thousands of dollars, making them attractive to thieves. If a collection were to be stolen, a standard homeowner’s insurance may not reimburse for the loss, leaving the collector to absorb the financial blow.

  • Damage from Natural Disasters: Natural disasters such as fire, floods, or hurricanes can lead to complete devastation of your home and belongings. A single incident could destroy years of passionate collecting, leaving you with nothing but memories of your prized sports card collection. Most homeowner’s insurance policies do not cover the specialized needs of high-value collectibles, which can be a significant oversight for collectors.

  • Accidental Damage to Your Card Collection: Accidents happen, and when they do, they can have severe consequences for your sports cards. Whether it’s a bent corner, a scratch, or exposure to water, accidental damage can significantly lower the value of your collection. Even minor incidents can lead to irreversible damage to valuable cards, resulting in unfortunate financial losses that could have been avoided with the right insurance coverage.

Why Partnering with Us Makes Sense

To ensure that your investment in sports cards is safe and secure, PCI’s specialized insurance coverage developed specifically for high-value collectibles is absolutely essential. This type of insurance not only protects your cards from theft and natural disasters but also provides coverage for accidental damage that a standard policy typically overlooks. Our specialized sports card insurance ensures that your collection is fully protected against all potential risks.

Whether you’re a casual collector or a serious investor, having the right insurance can provide peace of mind knowing that your investment is secure, no matter the circumstances. Don’t leave your sports cards vulnerable – consider the importance of specialized insurance for your high-value collectibles today!

Sports Card Insurance FAQ

Sports card insurance is a specialized policy designed to protect your sports card collection against risks such as theft, fire, water damage, and accidental loss. Unlike standard homeowner’s insurance, which often has limited coverage for collectibles, sports card insurance ensures your collection’s true value is covered. If you’re a passionate collector or retailer, this protection is essential for safeguarding your investment.

While homeowner’s insurance provides general coverage for personal belongings, it often excludes or limits coverage for high-value items like collectible cards. Sports card insurance offers tailored protection for the unique risks and values associated with collectibles, including specialized coverage options like market value insurance or agreed-upon value policies.

You can determine your collection’s value through professional appraisals, recent sales data, or using grading services like PSA or Beckett to establish the market value of your cards. Many insurance providers, including us, can help guide you through this process to ensure accurate coverage.

Yes, you can insure both graded and ungraded cards. However, graded cards typically have a higher insured value since their condition and authenticity are certified by a professional service. For ungraded cards, documentation of value (like receipts, photos, or appraisals) can help establish coverage.

PCI's policies provide comprehensive “all-risk” protection, including:

  • Theft: Coverage for stolen cards, whether at home, a show, or in transit.
  • Fire and Natural Disasters: Protection against events like fires, floods, and hurricanes.
  • Accidental Damage: Coverage for mishaps such as spills, drops, or bends.
  • Transit Damage: Protection for cards shipped to or from events or buyers.

Yes, most policies include coverage for cards taken to shows, trade events, or while traveling. This is often referred to as worldwide coverage. Ensure you inform your provider about frequent travel with your collection to confirm the specifics.

Yes, most policies have a deductible, but the amount can vary based on your chosen coverage plan. Some collectors prefer a higher deductible to lower premiums, while others opt for minimal deductibles to maximize claims payouts.

Absolutely. We offer inventory insurance for card shops and retailers. This covers your stock against risks like theft, fire, and water damage, as well as liability coverage for your business operations.

The claims process typically involves the following steps:

  1. Report the incident to your insurance provider.
  2. Provide proof of ownership and value (photos, receipts, or appraisals).
  3. Submit any police reports if applicable (e.g., for theft).
  4. Work with a claims adjuster who specializes in collectibles to assess the loss.
  5. Receive reimbursement based on your policy’s terms.

There are no strict limits, but the coverage amount depends on the appraised or documented value of your collection. High-value collections may require additional documentation or specific policies, such as scheduled personal property insurance for collectibles.

The cost of sports card insurance varies based on factors like the total value of your collection, the coverage options you select, and the deductible you choose. On average, premiums are a small percentage of your collection's insured value, making it an affordable way to protect your investment.

Yes, it’s important to update your policy when you add new cards to your collection to ensure they are covered. Many providers offer flexible policies that allow you to make adjustments easily as your collection grows.

Yes, many policies include coverage for collections stored in secure off-site locations like bank vaults or safety deposit boxes. Be sure to discuss the storage location with your provider to confirm coverage details.

Documentation requirements typically include:

  • A detailed inventory of your collection.
  • Photos or scans of individual cards.
  • Receipts for purchases or appraisals for high-value items.

Providing accurate records ensures a smooth claims process if needed.

Read our Latest Blog

The Paul Skenes 1/1 Rookie Card

How to Identify Rare Comic Books

How to Identify Rare Vinyl

Insurance for High-Value Items and Collectibles

Our team members bring a lifetime of passionate experience in collecting, which enriches our understanding of our clients’ unique needs and aspirations, especially when it comes to their prized possessions.

Private Collection Insurance (PCI) offers tailored insurance solutions designed to protect a wide range of rare and valuable items including, but not limited to Jewellery, Watches and Timepieces, Fine Art, Wine and Whiskey, Sports Cards, Comic Books, Memorabilia, Vinyl Records, Musical Instruments, Static Vehicle Collections, Coins, Firearms, Purses and Fashion, and other high-value memorabilia. We encourage you to click on the boxes below to learn more about our exclusive insurance for high-value collections.

JEWELLERY

Jewellery Insurance

Jewellery insurance protects valuable assets against theft, loss, or damage. High-value jewellery insurance offers essential protection for your most treasured items, including engagement rings, diamond bracelets, earrings, custom jewellery pieces, and cherished family heirlooms.

Learn more

SPORTS CARDS

Sports Card Insurance

Sports card insurance is ideal for card collections including rare cards, graded cards, autographed items, or game-used redemption cards. Our sports cards insurance policies may include replacement cost, coverage for display or storage, and protection during transport.

Learn more

WATCHES

Watch Insurance

Whether you own a single Rolex, heirloom timepiece or an extensive watch collection, our watch insurance covers theft, accidental damage, loss and more. Policies may include replacement cost, worldwide coverage, and protection during transit or display.

Learn more

FINE ART

Fine Art Insurance

Fine Art Insurance protects valuable art collections from theft, damage, and loss. We cover paintings, sculptures, and masterpieces and our policies may include replacement cost, transit protection, and specialized coverage for exhibitions or displays.

Learn more

MEMORABILIA

Memorabilia Insurance

Memorabilia could include rare and valuable collectible figures, historic artifacts, sports jerseys or commemorative pieces. Our memorabilia Insurance policies may include replacement cost, transit protection, and specialized coverage for exhibitions, private displays, or storage.

Coming Soon

WINE & WHISKEY

Rare Libation Insurance

Insurance for collections of fine wines, whiskey, spirits, and barrel-aged treasures. Whether stored in a cellar, displayed at home, or in transit, our wine and whiskey insurance policies provide comprehensive protection against theft and damage.

Learn more

VINYL RECORDS

Vinyl Collection Insurance

Insurance for vinyl record collections protects a cherished vinyl collection. Whether it's rare first pressings, colored variants, limited editions, or box sets, vinyl collection insurance ensures their treasures are protected.

Learn more

FIREARMS

Gun Insurance

Gun insurance offers protection for firearms collectors, covering theft, accidental damage, and liability. From rare firearms to sporting guns our policies may include replacement cost, transport protection, and liability for injuries or damages.

Learn more

MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS

Instrument Insurance

Musical instrument insurance protects treasured instruments, from classic guitars to grand pianos and rare violins, against theft, damage, or loss.

Learn more

STATIC VEHICLES

Vehicle Insurance

Static vehicles are showcased to preserve unique vehicles. Our vehicle collection insurance protects extensive collections, including exotic cars, motorcycles, and static vehicles from theft, damage, or loss. We also offer racetrack coverage.

Coming Soon

COINS & CURRENCY

Coin Collection Insurance

From antique to rare minted and commemorative coins we protect coin and currency collections from theft, damage, or loss.

Learn more

COMIC BOOKS

Comic Book Insurance

We protect rare, or limited edition comic book collections with our specialized comic book insurance against theft, damage, or loss. Whether stored, displayed, or in use, our policies ensure these valuable accessories are fully protected.

Learn more